Is it worth a spot on your shelf?

A 12-shade eyeshadow palette pairing neutral mattes with shimmer shades.

The appeal: Its appeal is everyday versatility. Allure’s reviewer describes it as a favorite for casual glam, rather than a palette built around bold color. Allure review (2021)

The tradeoff: A neutral palette can duplicate what is already in your drawer. Check how many of these particular shades you would use before choosing another set.

Our take: A useful starting point for neutral eye looks; less compelling if you already have a well-used set of similar shades.