Is it worth a spot on your shelf?

A 14-shade eyeshadow palette with neutral mattes and brighter shimmer finishes.

The appeal: The mix lets you build a softer everyday eye or add shine for a more dressed-up look without switching palettes. Sephora

The tradeoff: Its strength is a coordinated neutral color story. If you already have those shades covered, the overlap may matter more than having another palette.

Our take: A useful option for a neutral makeup wardrobe, especially if you will use both the mattes and the shimmers.