Is it worth a spot on your shelf?

A 14-shade eyeshadow palette combining everyday neutrals with red and berry tones.

The appeal: You can keep a look neutral or bring in the warmer, richer shades. The color story is the main reason to choose it over a basic brown palette. Anastasia Beverly Hills

The tradeoff: If you rarely use reds or berry shades, part of the palette may go untouched. Compare the actual colors with the neutrals you already own.

Our take: A more interesting pick for warm, romantic eye looks than for someone seeking only understated browns.